release(v0.5.1): hotfix — quota probe cache/backoff/schema-drift correctness (codex review) (#58)

* release(v0.5.1): hotfix — quota probe cache/backoff/schema-drift correctness (codex review)

Addresses three production-quality findings from codex's post-v0.5.0 review (codex review on
PR #57, reproduced with local mocks):

F1 [P1] — Doctor bypass of cache + backoff (ADR 0013 Rule 3)
  `anthropic.quota_probe_reachable` called `_probeOnce(auth)` directly, bypassing
  `quotaProbeState.backoffUntil`. Successive `olp doctor` invocations within a backoff
  window each hit upstream — violating ADR 0013 Rule 3 (backoff is mandatory for ALL
  consumers). Fix: doctor now routes through `quotaStatus()`. ADR 0013 Rule 3 clarified:
  "All consumers of `quotaStatus()`, including `olp doctor` checks, MUST route through
  `quotaStatus()` and MUST NOT call `_probeOnce()` directly."

F2 [P2] — 200 with empty ratelimit headers cached as live data (ADR 0013 Rule 5)
  A 200 OK with zero `anthropic-ratelimit-*` headers was cached as `stale: false` (live).
  Minimum-viable-schema gate added to `_probeOnce`: requires 5h-utilization + 5h-reset +
  7d-utilization + 7d-reset present; absence → `failureKind: 'schema_drift'`, backoff
  scheduled, result NOT cached. ADR 0013 Rule 5 updated with the gate specification.

F3 [P2] — Dashboard-data loses failure detail (ADR 0013 Rule 6)
  `aggregateProviderQuota()` collapsed all failure modes into `status: 'unavailable'`
  ("no public quota api or probe disabled") — same as providers with no API at all.
  Fix: `quotaStatus()` v0.5.1 contract — `null` ONLY for opt-in-off; failures return
  `{ probe_status: 'unreachable', failure: { kind, message, backoff_until? } }`.
  New `failure_kind` enum: no_credentials | auth_failed | rate_limited | schema_drift |
  network | other. Dashboard renders `unreachable` with red border + failure detail.

Authority:
  ADR 0013 Rules 3, 5, 6 (cache + backoff + schema-drift + failure transparency)
  ADR 0008 Amendment 2 (richer quota_v2 shape; new unreachable status)
  ADR 0002 Amendment 8 unchanged (constitutional permission for the probe)
  Codex review findings F1–F3 (codex on PR #57)

Changes:
  - lib/providers/anthropic.mjs: quotaProbeState gains lastError + failureKind;
    _probeOnce: min-field gate + failureKind population; quotaStatus(): v0.5.1 contract
    (null=disabled only; probe_status:live/stale/unreachable); doctorChecks routes
    through quotaStatus(); reset functions updated
  - lib/audit-query.mjs: _normalizeAnthropicQuota handles probe_status field;
    aggregateProviderQuota emits failure/failure_kind/backoff_until; unreachable status
  - dashboard.html: unreachable CSS classes + render path + footer v0.5.1
  - test-features.mjs: 38f/j/l updated for v0.5.1 shape; 38r refactored for F1;
    38g/k gain probe_status assertions; 38u/v/w new regression tests; 756→759 tests
  - docs/adr/0008: Amendment 2 (richer ProviderQuotaEntry + quotaStatus contract)
  - docs/adr/0013: Rule 3 clarification (doctor must use quotaStatus);
    Rule 5 min-viable-schema gate specification
  - package.json: 0.5.0 → 0.5.1
  - CHANGELOG.md: v0.5.1 hotfix entry promoted from Unreleased
  - README.md / AGENTS.md: Phase 5 closed at v0.5.1; Phase 6 next

Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.6 <noreply@anthropic.com>

* docs+code: PR #58 fold-in — reviewer Nits #1 + #2 (ADR doc-drift + opt_in_off enum)

Fresh-context reviewer (PR #58) verdict: APPROVE_WITH_MINOR, 0 blocking,
4 nits. Folding in #1 + #2 (both 1-line cosmetic-but-correct fixes).
Deferring #3 (test-only edge case in module-level seam restore) and #4
(pre-existing codex F4 — bin/olp.mjs + olp-plugin still read legacy
quota shape; separate PR planned).

Nit #1 — ADR 0002 Amendment 8 documentation drift.

Amendment 8 at v0.5.0 line 20 said "the function returns `null` rather
than throwing", and line 33 said "stale-cache-on-failure (`null` is
returned only when no cache entry exists; if a stale entry exists it's
returned with a `stale: true` marker)". v0.5.1 refined this contract:
`null` is now reserved STRICTLY for opt-in-off, and all failure modes
return `{ probe_status: 'unreachable' | 'stale', failure: {...} }`.

The substantive idempotent-failure constraint (no throw to caller) is
unchanged. The operational description in Amendment 8 was stale — fixed
to cross-reference ADR 0008 Amendment 2 + ADR 0013 Rule 6 for the
v0.5.1 contract refinement. Also references Suite 38 (38u/38v/38w) as
the regression coverage producing the new shape.

Nit #2 — `failureKind: 'opt_in_off'` declared but never produced.

The enum value was listed in both the code comment (anthropic.mjs:250)
and ADR 0008 Amendment 2 (line 30) but never actually assigned —
because when opt-in is off, `quotaStatus()` returns the literal `null`
BEFORE any state mutation happens. The enum value was dead.

Fix: removed `opt_in_off` from both enum declarations + added an
inline note explaining that consumers (audit-query, doctor) distinguish
opt-in-off by checking `quotaStatus() === null`, not via failureKind.

Deferred:

- Nit #3 (test-seam restore edge case): if a caller pre-sets
  `_quotaAuthReadFnForTest` AND passes a non-default `_authReadFn`,
  the finally block restores to null clobbering pre-set value.
  Test-only impact, no production risk. Pure hygiene; defer.

- Nit #4 (codex F4): bin/olp.mjs cmdUsage and olp-plugin/index.js
  still read legacy `body.quota` field, never consume `quota_v2`.
  Reviewer confirmed neither crashes — both gracefully fall through
  to "no quota api" branch. Out of scope for this hotfix per the
  hotfix dispatch contract; separate PR will migrate them.

Tests: 759/759 still pass post-fold-in. No test changes needed.

Authority: PR #58 review thread + ADR 0013 Rule 6 (failure transparency)
+ ADR 0008 Amendment 2 (ProviderQuotaEntry v0.5.1 shape).

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com>

---------

Co-authored-by: dtzp555 <dtzp555@gmail.com>
Co-authored-by: Claude Sonnet 4.6 <noreply@anthropic.com>

AGENTS.md

@@ -49,7 +49,7 @@ Runtime: Node.js (ESM, `.mjs` throughout). No build step. No bundler. `server.mj
 - `.github/workflows/alignment.yml` — CI blacklist grep + per-provider citation soft check; fails the build on known-hallucinated tokens.
 - `CLAUDE.md` — Claude-Code-specific session instructions + `release_kit` overlay (Iron Rule 5.5).
 
-**Implementation status note (as of 2026-05-25):** Files marked 📋 above are designed and documented but not yet on disk; files marked 🟡 are partially shipped; files marked ✅ are Phase 2 deliverables. The shipped set as of D47 is: `server.mjs` (with Phase 2 auth middleware + audit wire + owner-vs-non-owner gating), `lib/ir/`, `lib/providers/{anthropic,codex,mistral}.mjs`, `lib/cache/{keys,store}.mjs`, `lib/fallback/engine.mjs`, `lib/keys.mjs` (core + loadAuthConfigSync — D44 + D45), `lib/audit.mjs` (D45), `bin/olp-keys.mjs` (D47), `models-registry.json`, `test-features.mjs` (Suites 19–22). Phase 2 functional scope is complete; remaining is Phase 2 close → v0.2.0 (maintainer-triggered, explicit per CLAUDE.md `release_kit.phase_close_trigger`).
+**Implementation status note (as of 2026-05-27):** Phase 5 (Quota Probes + Dashboard Enrichment) is closed at v0.5.0 + v0.5.1 hotfix. The shipped set includes all Phases 1–5 deliverables. v0.5.1 hotfix (2026-05-27) fixes three codex review findings: F1 (doctor check bypassed backoff by calling `_probeOnce` directly — now routes through `quotaStatus()`), F2 (200 with empty `anthropic-ratelimit-*` headers was cached as live — minimum-viable-schema gate added), F3 (null collapsed all failure modes — `probe_status:'unreachable'` shape + `failure`/`failure_kind`/`backoff_until` fields added). See ADR 0008 Amendment 2 + ADR 0013 Rule 3/5 clarifications. Phase 6 is next (per CLAUDE.md `release_kit.current_phase`).
 
 ---