taodeng/olp
1
0
Fork 0
mirror of https://github.com/dtzp555-max/olp.git synced 2026-07-19 09:45:07 +00:00
Code Issues Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity

docs(governance): fold in 6 codex review findings

Browse Source 
External Codex CLI review surfaced 6 substantive findings beyond what
the internal opus reviewer caught at D1. All folded in this commit.
Files changed: ALIGNMENT.md, README.md, ADR 0001, ADR 0006, CHANGELOG.

1. Provider Inventory split: Candidate vs Enabled
   - Bootstrap previously listed anthropic/openai/mistral as Tier D
     default-enabled with Authority pins still "TBD at Phase N spawn".
     This violated Rule 1 (Cite First) and Rule 3 (Match Implementation).
   - v0.1 founding now ships 0 Enabled Providers. All 8 are Candidate.
     Enablement requires: authority pin filled + plugin landed + Phase
     audit passed.

2. Antigravity Tier A downgraded to "evidence-backed pending pin"
   - Secondary reports disagree on blast radius (piunikaweb 03-02 says
     AI-tier only; piunikaweb 02-23 + OpenClaw issue + VentureBeat say
     broader). Google FAQ language naming OpenClaw/OpenCode/Claude Code
     is cited from secondary sources only — primary URL not pinned.
   - Exclusion remains active by default; constitutional weight matches
     evidence. Primary-source pinning tracked as one-shot audit task
     with 90-day Tier-reconsideration trigger.

3. ADR 0001 supersession scope narrowed
   - Previous draft claimed OLP is "the structural shape ADR 0005
     endorsed," but ADR 0005's separate-repo recommendation came with
     "BYOK from day one" + "no cli.js spawn" qualifiers OLP rejects.
   - Supersession now narrowly scoped to "single-provider-sufficiency
     premise only"; BYOK + no-spawn parts of ADR 0005 explicitly NOT
     inherited.

4. Anthropic post-2026-06-15 one-shot audit scheduled
   - Annual 14 May audit would leave the Anthropic Tier re-eval almost
     a year late after the 2026-06-15 split.
   - Added one-shot audit for 2026-06-16 (or first billing-cycle close)
     verifying observed behaviour matches spec §2 assumptions.

5. Tier A "permanent" wording unified
   - ALIGNMENT.md and ADR 0006 disagreed (permanent vs amendable).
     Unified as "Excluded by default. Cannot be re-included unless
     ADR 0006 is superseded/amended with new primary-source evidence."

6. OpenAI Tier D wording softened
   - Discussion #8338 was framed as "maintainer confirmed permissive";
     actual quote is a maintainer posture statement with explicit "I'm
     an engineer, not a lawyer" caveat.
   - Now: "maintainer signal indicates low risk; formal ToS pin pending."

Reviewer: OpenAI Codex CLI (external, fresh-context). Iron Rule 10
satisfied — internal opus reviewer was not the source of these
findings; reviewer and maintainer are distinct.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
taodeng
2026-05-23 16:21:37 +10:00
co-authored by Claude Opus 4.7
parent c5777aa4d7
commit 91223ee9ab
5 changed files with 90 additions and 34 deletions
Download Patch File Download Diff File Expand all files Collapse all files
README.md
+15 -11
View File
@@ -43,20 +43,24 @@ olp start
Source of truth: [`models-registry.json`](./models-registry.json). This table is regenerated from the registry per the [`release_kit`](./CLAUDE.md) overlay; do not edit it out of sync.
| Provider key | CLI | Subscription / auth | Risk Tier (per [ADR 0006](./docs/adr/0006-provider-inclusion.md)) | Default state |
OLP distinguishes **Candidate Providers** (declared as intended, not yet pinned) from **Enabled Providers** (authority pin filled + plugin landed + Phase audit passed). The v0.1 founding commit ships **zero Enabled Providers** — enablement is a Phase audit deliverable, not a bootstrap claim. See [`ALIGNMENT.md` § Provider Inventory](./ALIGNMENT.md) for the transition gate.
### Candidate Providers
| Provider key | CLI | Subscription / auth | Anticipated Tier | Anticipated Phase |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| `anthropic` | `claude -p` | Pro / Max OAuth (pre-2026-06-15); Agent SDK Credit pool after | D (re-eval post-2026-06-15) | Enabled |
| `openai` | `codex exec --json` | ChatGPT Pro OAuth or API key | D | Enabled |
| `mistral` | `vibe --prompt --output json` | Le Chat Pro API key | D | Enabled |
| `grok` | `grok -p --output-format streaming-json` | xAI Build `xai-...` API key | C | Disabled (opt-in) |
| `kimi` | `kimi -p --output-format stream-json` | Moonshot Kimi API key | C | Disabled (opt-in) |
| `minimax` | TBD | MiniMax Token Plan (¥29+/mo) | B | Disabled (consent required) |
| `glm` | TBD | Zhipu Coding Plan ($10+/mo) | B | Disabled (consent required) |
| `qwen` | TBD | Alibaba Coding Plan ($50/mo) | B | Disabled (consent required) |
| `anthropic` | `claude -p` | Pro / Max OAuth (pre-2026-06-15); Agent SDK Credit pool after | D (re-eval post-2026-06-15) | Phase 1 |
| `openai` | `codex exec --json` | ChatGPT Pro OAuth or API key | D | Phase 2 |
| `mistral` | `vibe --prompt --output json` | Le Chat Pro API key | D | Phase 3 |
| `grok` | `grok -p --output-format streaming-json` | xAI Build `xai-...` API key | C | Phase 8+ |
| `kimi` | `kimi -p --output-format stream-json` | Moonshot Kimi API key | C | Phase 8+ |
| `minimax` | TBD | MiniMax Token Plan (¥29+/mo) | B | Phase 8+ |
| `glm` | TBD | Zhipu Coding Plan ($10+/mo) | B | Phase 8+ |
| `qwen` | TBD | Alibaba Coding Plan ($50/mo) | B | Phase 8+ |
**Risk tier guide.** D = permissive / safe; C = tightening signal, no enforcement history; B = service-level key revocation risk, vendor may extend across that vendor's AI services; A = permanently excluded. Tier B providers prompt for explicit consent on first enable and record consent in `~/.olp/config.json`. See [`ALIGNMENT.md` § Risk Tier Framework](./ALIGNMENT.md#risk-tier-framework).
**Risk tier guide.** D = permissive / safe (eligible for default-enabled); C = tightening signal, no enforcement history (opt-in); B = service-level key revocation risk (opt-in + consent); A = excluded by default (cannot be opt-in enabled). Tier B providers prompt for explicit consent on first enable and record consent in `~/.olp/config.json`. See [`ALIGNMENT.md` § Risk Tier Framework](./ALIGNMENT.md#risk-tier-framework).
**Excluded permanently (Tier A).** Google Antigravity. See [ADR 0006](./docs/adr/0006-provider-inclusion.md) for the named-prohibition + no-cost-advantage + reinstatement-friction rationale.
**Excluded by default (Tier A — evidence-backed, pending primary-source pin).** Google Antigravity. See [ADR 0006](./docs/adr/0006-provider-inclusion.md) for the named-prohibition + no-cost-advantage + reinstatement-friction rationale, and for the primary-source pinning follow-up that may force a Tier reconsideration if the Google FAQ language cannot be sourced within 90 days of 2026-05-23.
---